American

Michter’s US*1 Toasted Barrel Finish Kentucky Straight Rye Review

Can a toasted, uncharred barrel convert someone who swears they hate rye? We taste Michter's 2026 US*1 Toasted Barrel Finish Rye to find out.

OVERALL RATING

9
Like Conversation

Tasting Notes

About:

Michter’s Distillery will release its US*1 Toasted Barrel Finish Rye this September, bottled at barrel strength. The launch follows the Louisville, Kentucky-based producer being named The World’s #1 Most Admired Whiskey for a fourth consecutive year.

The rye is finished in a second barrel that is toasted, but not charred. Michter’s Master Distiller Dan McKee and Master of Maturation Andrea Wilson led production of the 2026 release.

The wood used for the second barrel was air-dried and seasoned outdoors for 24 months before being toasted to exact specifications. “As our production team pursues our goal of striving to make the best American whiskey, we employ time-honored, traditional Kentucky methods, and we supplement them with our research and innovations,” said Michter’s President Joseph J. Magliocco. “This is what led our team to create a new category when, in 2014, we launched the first Toasted Barrel Bourbon finished in a second barrel that had been toasted, but not charred.” McKee outlined the care behind the finishing process.

“A great deal of thought and detail goes into the creation of our Toasted Barrel Finish releases,” he said. “The fully matured whiskey that we put into the second barrel for finishing and the particular toast level of that second barrel have to be just right to achieve the perfect balance.”

He added: “This year’s release is another great example of how our team marries art and science to create an amazing whiskey.”
Appearance:
A clear middle ground between tawny and mahogany. Thin quick legs which don’t really linger. Tasted neat, after resting, in a Glencairn glass.
Nose:
Sublte soft Kentucky rye with warm stewed apples cloaked in cinnamon. The notes of the nose are buttery and round with touches of butterscotch candy. First blush you’ll find green apples (nicely tart) before a moment of oak tannins.
Palate:
Oily mouthfeel with a classic robust rye profile cloaked in a meringue.

It has a pop without shouting. The oak is present, but the toasted barrel provides a soft sweetness without much deeper sugars. Well-rounded. The richness and unique profile of Kentucky Rye begins to take shape with malts, light teas, and young cigar filler. I find a soft toasted almond sweetness helps complete the profile.
Finish:
We graduate smoothly to the finish. It holds well with long touches of earth and dried grains. We see dark, warm oak fading into a touch of dark sugar.
Comments:
I revisited this one more than a couple of times because it kept evolving. I really enjoy a well-curated rye, and this is that. Rye, as a grain, is difficult to grow in Kentucky’s climate. The strain that does well in the Kentucky weather provides a different profile compared to the grain that grows more favorably in the Northeast.

Meaning the curation of a Kentucky Rye is a moment which should catch a studious eye. This bottle does a wonderful job finishing a complex rye in a barrel that doesn’t try to do too much. It really lets the rye speak for itself while elevating the microphone. This is a great bottle to show off, and something fans of rye will really love. To me, this is one of those rye bottles to give to the person who swears they ‘hate’ rye.

Editor’s Note: This whiskey was either bought as a sample by The Whiskey Wash or provided to us as a review sample by the party behind it. Per our editorial policies, this in no way influenced the outcome of this review.

Charles Steele

Charles Steele, a Portland-based attorney, is a native of the Pacific Northwest. His legal background provides him with an analytical approach to understanding whiskey and other aged spirits. Primarily a legal writer, freelancing for The Whiskey Wash offers Charles a unique opportunity to showcase his versatility as a writer. Although his preference lies with whiskey and whiskey-based cocktails, he has a profound appreciation for all unique and unconventional liquors, from Malört to Ojen - if it's peculiar, he's intrigued.

All Posts

Latest On The Whiskey Wash