Blanton’s is easily one of the most recognizable bottles in bourbon, thanks to its iconic bottle and horse & jockey stoppers. For a long time, the hard part for bourbon lovers was finding a bottle. While it is a little easier to find a bottle today, the price of Blanton’s Single Barrel has risen sharply in the USA. In the UK, you can still expect to pay around £80.
Four Roses Single Barrel has come up in several of our Blanton’s alternatives pieces, including 7 Bourbons to Buy Instead of Blanton’s and 5 Bourbons to Choose Over Blanton’s. It is buttery, rich, delicious, and cheaper than its Blanton’s counterpart.
For most buyers, then, the question is whether Blanton’s is worth the extra money. To find out, I compared the two on flavor, price, availability, and how well each works as a gift.
Blanton’s & Four Roses Single Barrel At A Glance
Both are single-barrel Kentucky bourbons. Four Roses is bottled at 100 proof, a little higher than Blanton’s at 93 proof, and it costs a good deal less. For me, Four Roses is the better bourbon to drink and the better use of your money.
Blanton’s is the better gift, especially for someone who will enjoy the bottle and stopper as much as the bourbon, as long as you’re comfortable paying the higher price.
Four Roses also makes a very good gift, particularly for someone who already knows their bourbon.
What’s In Each Bottle
Blanton’s Original Single Barrel
Blanton’s is made at Buffalo Trace in Frankfort, Kentucky, where Elmer T. Lee, then the distillery’s master distiller, introduced it in 1984 as the first single barrel bourbon sold commercially. He named it after his mentor, Albert B. Blanton, a former distillery manager who was known for pouring whiskey from his favorite “honey barrels” for visiting guests. Lee based Blanton’s on the same idea of bottling individual standout barrels
Blanton’s Original Single Barrel uses Buffalo Trace Mash Bill #2, the distillery’s higher-rye recipe.. The barrels come from Warehouse H, which Buffalo Trace calls “the only metal-clad warehouse at Buffalo Trace.”
There’s no age statement on the label, but Blanton’s is usually aged for around six to eight years. It’s bottled at 93 proof (46.5% ABV).
Four Roses Single Barrel
Four Roses produces ten bourbon recipes at its distillery in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky, and the standard Single Barrel always uses one of them, known as OBSV. The mash bill is 60% corn, 35% rye, and 5% malted barley, and it’s paired with the V yeast strain, which Four Roses describes as “delicate fruit.”
The Single Barrel is aged 7-9 years and bottled at 100 proof (50% ABV) in the US and in the UK. Our best value single barrel bourbon piece explains how the ten-recipe system works.
E. & J. Gallo completed its purchase of Four Roses from Kirin in April, with master distiller Brent Elliott and team remaining at the distillery.
Blanton’s vs. Four Roses Single Barrel: How They Taste
Blanton’s Original Single Barrel
Blanton’s opens with nutmeg, honey, and vanilla on the nose, along with orange citrus, baking spices, and some toasted oak. The palate starts sweet and then moves into orange, lemon, and brown sugar, with a little vanilla, rye spice, and oak following behind. The finish is medium in length, with caramel, leather, oak, pepper, and a light touch of tobacco.
It’s approachable and tasty, and there’s no question it’s a very good bourbon. Even so, I found it hard to justify the price on flavor alone.
Four Roses Single Barrel
The nose on Four Roses is spiced and fruity, with pear, peaches, vanilla, milk chocolate, cinnamon, nutmeg, caramel, butter, and nuts. It has a thick, creamy mouthfeel, and the palate starts with butter, caramel, cherry, and peach before wood spice, dark chocolate, mint, rosemary, and cinnamon come through. The finish is long, with fizzy cherry sweets, more caramel and butter, and a slightly medicinal hint of rosemary and lemon.
I love this bourbon. It’s one I reach for again and again, and at its price I think it’s a real bargain.
The scores elsewhere point the same way. Phil Dwyer gave Blanton’s 8/10 and Four Roses Single Barrel 9/10 in his reviews.
How Much Does Single-Barrel Variation Matter?
Every bottle of either bourbon comes from one barrel, so no two will taste exactly the same. Reviewers have generally found both to be fairly consistent, though. Every standard Four Roses Single Barrel uses the OBSV recipe, is bottled at 100 proof, and falls within the brand’s seven-to-nine-year age range. It is remarkably consistent between batches.
Jordan Moskal at Breaking Bourbon said something similar about Blanton’s, noting that it “could easily vary widely barrel to barrel, yet rarely does.”
Whichever you buy, you can expect small differences from bottle to bottle rather than a very different bourbon each time.
The Price Question
Blatnon’s starts at around $72 in the US, with prices at other retailers rising to $120. Four Roses Single Barrel starts at around $40, so depending on where you shop, you could buy close to two bottles of Four Roses for the price of one Blanton’s.
The gap is a little smaller in the UK. The cheapest Blanton’s listed on our comparison site is £72 at Royal Mile Whiskies, and it climbs to £90 on Amazon, while Four Roses starts at around £43. Four Roses is also the easier of the two to find in both countries, so you’re less likely to be stuck choosing between a long search and a marked-up bottle.
Four Roses has also been steady on price. As we noted in our look at value bourbons cheaper than Blanton’s, it has “barely changed in price over the last five years.”
Which Makes The Better Gift?
Blanton’s is an iconic bourbon to gift. The round, decanter-style bottle is instantly recognizable, and each one is topped with a horse-and-jockey stopper carrying one of the eight letters in B-L-A-N-T-O-N-S. Buffalo Trace says the stoppers are added at random, so anyone hoping to collect all eight will need to buy quite a few bottles.
If you’re buying for someone who will enjoy displaying the bottle as much as drinking what’s in it, Blanton’s is the better gift, as long as you’re comfortable with the price.
Four Roses still makes a very good gift. The brand redesigned its bottles in 2023, adding a raised rose emblem on the front and an engraved rose design on the cork, and it looks smart on a shelf.
For someone who would rather drink the bourbon than display the bottle, I’d happily give Four Roses, and the money you save could go toward something else to go with it.
Blanton’s vs Four Roses Single Barrel: Which Should You Buy?
Both are very good bourbons, and I’d happily accept a glass of either one. For drinking, though, Four Roses Single Barrel is the bottle I’d buy every time. It is significantly cheaper and, honestly, I think I prefer the flavor over Blanton’s anyway.
If you want the better bourbon: Four Roses Single Barrel.
If you want the better value: Four Roses Single Barrel, by a wide margin.
If you’re buying a gift for someone who loves the bottle and the stoppers: Blanton’s, as long as you’re prepared to pay for it.
If you’re buying a gift for someone who simply loves good bourbon: Four Roses Single Barrel.
If you’d like to look at a few more options, our Blanton’s vs Eagle Rare 10 comparison and our list of 7 bourbons to buy instead of Blanton’s are good places to start. Let us know in the comments which of these two you’d pick.








