If “smooth and balanced” is your jam, wheated bourbon might be your best friend. Looking for some great recommendations? Here’s where to start, without chasing those unicorn bottles.
Wheated bourbon swaps rye for wheat in the mash bill, dialling down spice and letting vanilla, honeyed grain, and orchard fruit step forward. Whilst there are some highly sought-after wheated bourbons such as your Pappy Van Winkles and 1792 Sweet Wheat, this list focuses on five approachable, good-value wheated bourbons you can actually find and enjoy right now.
1) Weller Special Reserve — the most gentle entry point
Buffalo Trace’s gateway wheater is soft, honeyed, and easy-drinking, with green apple, vanilla fudge, and a rounded mid-palate. It’s the bottle many people use to figure out if they’re “a wheated person.” It also makes a fantastic Old Fashioned, with a lighter touch on the bitters to let the fruit show. I poured a Weller Special Reserve side-by-side with a rye-recipe bourbon for a couple of “I don’t drink bourbon” friends. The Weller’s fruit and creaminess won them over immediately, one described it as “apple crumble with a spoon of custard,” which isn’t far off.
SHOP HERE: £38.95 (Worldwide Shipping Available from Royal Mile Whiskies, currently £5 off)
(Brand info: Buffalo Trace Distillery)
Must Read Stories
2) Maker’s Mark — classic, consistent, everywhere
It’s easy to overlook Maker’s Mark because it’s everywhere but that red-wax classic is popular for a reason. Expect caramel, gentle baking spice, and a creamy texture that holds up neat, on the rocks, or in cocktails. I always keep a bottle around as a another “bourbon converter” nine times out of ten, Maker’s is the pour that changes people’s mind on many negative preconceptions they might have had towards bourbons. If you want a little more oak polish and cocoa without losing the wheated core, Maker’s Mark Cellar Aged adds complexity from the limestone cellar ageing that deepens flavour without turning the dial to “oaky.”
SHOP HERE: £31.96
Read more: Maker’s Mark brand guide.
(Brand info: Maker’s Mark)
3) Leiper’s Fork Bottled-in-Bond — craft-distillery character with real backbone
From Franklin, Tennessee, Leiper’s Fork Bottled-in-Bond brings a little more structure while staying true to the wheated character. Bottled at 100 proof (50% ABV) and aged at least four years in a single distilling season, it balances toffee and orange oil with toasted oak and a grain-forward mid-palate that feels substantial without turning hot. The first time I poured this with a group, the comment that stuck was “buttered cornbread with marmalade,” which captures the richer, more textural side of wheated bourbon beautifully.
SHOP HERE: £68.95
Related reading: Why Bottled-in-Bond is Important
Brand info: Leiper’s Fork Distillery
4) Ben Holladay Rickhouse Proof (Soft Red Wheat) — craft with credibility
If you want to feel what extra strength does to a wheated profile, Ben Holladay’s Rickhouse Proof is the move. It keeps the soft, rounded wheat character but turns up the volume: think caramel brittle and vanilla bean up front, baked apple and stone fruit in the middle, then toasted pecan, oak spice, and a little tobacco warmth on the finish. It’s bold without getting jagged, the kind of pour that rewards a slow swirl and a few minutes in the glass.
SHOP HERE: £96.95 (Currently £10 off at Royal Mile Whiskies)
(Brand info: Holladay Distillery)
5) Willett Pot Still Reserve Straight Bourbon — elegant, citrus-forward sipper
Don’t let the showpiece bottle fool you, the whiskey inside is just as impressive. Willett Pot Still Reserve leans bright and polished: vanilla cream and honeyed corn up front, then lemon oil, light baking spice and a clean oak finish. It reads silky rather than heavy, it pairs well in a whiskey flight next to a Weller as you get that lift of citrus and spice without losing the easy sipping character of a classic wheated bourbon.
SHOP HERE: £75.95 (Currently £10 off at Royal Mile Whiskies)
(Brand info: Willett Distillery)
Why These Five?
These bottles were selected for their availability (especially in the UK via retailers that ship internationally), consistent quality for the money and a useful spread of proofs and profiles, from the gentle, fruit-forward ease of Weller Special Reserve to the structured craft character of Leiper’s Fork BIB, with Maker’s Mark anchoring the “always good, always findable” middle ground. If you want alternates on the potentially less available side, consider David Nicholson 1843 as another value wheater, or the occasional Old Fitzgerald BIB drop when you spot one.
