A Whiskey and Coke is a classic highball. Simple, refreshing, and easy to make. Most people default to Jack Daniel’s, but you do not have to.
With a few quick swaps, you can turn this everyday mix into something more flavorful and stylish. Here are four simple steps to upgrade your Whiskey and Coke from a lacklustre go-to to a staple of your bar.
Swap 1: Try Out a Different Whiskey
Jack Daniel’s may be the go-to for a Whiskey and Coke, but there are plenty of options that add more depth without being too expensive. The right whiskey should have enough flavor to stand up to the sweetness of cola.
Buffalo Trace (Bourbon)
This Kentucky bourbon is praised for its balance of oak, vanilla, and spice. In a blind tasting by Uproxx, it even beat Jack Daniel’s when mixed with cola, thanks to its richer and slightly spicier profile. It adds warmth and complexity while still feeling familiar.
Bulleit Rye (Rye Whiskey)
If you prefer a bolder edge, Bulleit Rye is a strong choice. Rye whiskeys bring notes of pepper and clove that cut through the sweetness of cola. The result is a Whiskey and Coke with more bite and character.
Jameson (Irish Whiskey)
For a lighter style, Jameson is smooth, clean, and easy to drink. Irish whiskey is triple distilled, giving it a crisp finish that blends seamlessly with cola. It makes for a softer, mellow version of the drink.
A solid mid-range whiskey with distinct character will make your Whiskey and Coke taste better without stretching your budget.
Swap 2: Try a Different Cola in Your Whiskey & Coke
Cola is half the drink, so the type you use matters. Standard Coca-Cola works, but changing the mixer can transform the flavor. Here are three easy upgrades.
Mexican Coca-Cola
Made with cane sugar instead of corn syrup, Mexican Coke has a cleaner sweetness and smoother finish. Fans often say it feels more natural and less sharp.
Craft Colas
Boutique brands like Fentimans Curiosity Cola add layers of spice and botanicals. In a Whiskey and Coke, that extra complexity makes the drink taste closer to a crafted cocktail than a simple highball.
Flavored Colas
Cherry Coke, Vanilla Coke, or even Pepsi can change the balance. Cherry adds a dark fruit note, while vanilla highlights the caramel and oak in bourbon. These variations are easy to find and give the drink a fresh twist.
Swap 3: Ditch the Ice for Whiskey Stones
Ice is classic, but it melts and waters down your drink. Whiskey stones keep your Whiskey and Coke cold without changing the flavor.
Soapstone Stones
These give a gentle chill and will not scratch your glass. They lower the temperature enough to refresh without muting the taste.
Stainless Steel Stones
These cubes get colder than soapstone and stay that way longer. They are sleek, practical, and perfect if you like your drink very cold.
Both options are reusable and easy to keep in the freezer.
Swap 4: Add a Garnish or Bitters
A standard Whiskey and Coke usually comes with nothing on top. Adding a garnish or a dash of bitters is an easy way to lift the drink.
Citrus
A wedge of lime or a twist of lemon brightens the sweetness and adds fresh aroma. It works the same way as in a rum and Coke.
Angostura Bitters
Just a couple of drops bring spice and depth. Bartenders use this trick to add complexity without changing the drink’s identity.
Cocktail Cherries
A maraschino or Luxardo cherry adds color and a hint of sweetness. It also makes the drink feel more like a crafted cocktail.
These small touches take seconds but change how the drink looks, smells, and tastes.
Enjoy Your Whiskey & Coke The Way You Like It
A Whiskey and Coke does not have to be basic. By swapping the whiskey, cola, ice, or garnish, you can turn it into a drink with more flavor and style. None of these upgrades are expensive or complicated.
How do you enjoy your Whiskey and Coke? Share your favorite twist with us.
Latest On The Whiskey Wash
