Independent bottlings, age statements and added complexity – natural next-steps from Laphroaig 10.
Peat isn’t one note. It can be medicinal and maritime (iodine, sea spray), bonfire and BBQ, even cocoa and dried fruit when sherry casks get involved. If you love the bracing coastal/medicinal hit of Laphroaig 10, the five bottles below show where to go next, higher age statements, sherry-led depth, and indie bottlings with serious character.
Signup now to make sure you don't miss out on the latest whiskey news and deals.
By Signing up, you accept and agree to our Terms of Services and you acknowledge our Privacy Statement. The Whiskey Wash is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Signup now to make sure you don't miss out on the latest whiskey news and deals.
By Signing up, you accept and agree to our Terms of Services and you acknowledge our Privacy Statement. The Whiskey Wash is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
New to peat? Start with our Guide to Peat Levels in Whisky.
1) Laphroaig 18 Year Old – the more nuanced version of a classic
Laphroaig 10 is all crashing waves and antiseptic. Laphroaig 18 keeps the Atlantic in the glass but smooths the edges: smouldering peat and iodine wrapped in lemon oil, heather honey, vanilla and polished oak. The smoke turns from flare-up to embers.
Why I recommend it: It’s the “aha” upgrade for Laphroaig fans, house character, just calmer and deeper. If you already love 10, 18 feels like the same coastline at golden hour.
Best for: Fans of Laphroaig 10 who want more depth, less bite.
Must Read Stories
SHOP NOW: £179.95 (Currently £10 off at Royal Mile Whiskies)
2) Lagavulin 16 – silk-smoke and dried fruit
If Laphroaig is the sea, Lagavulin 16 is the harbour library: polished oak, tea-like tannin, dried fruit and rich, silky smoke. Gentler than Laphroaig’s medicinal strike, but the finish lingers and lingers.
Why I recommend it: It softens iodine into incense. This is the bottle that converts non-peated whisky drinkers when they’re ready to dip their toes into smoke.
Best for: A contemplative pour that softens iodine into incense.
SHOP NOW: £81.95
3) Bowmore 2011 14 Year Old “Decadent Drams” (53%) – tropical-coastal indie charm
This Decadent Drams Bowmore shows the distillery’s other gear: sea spray, citrus peel, vanilla and that classic Bowmore tropical lift (think mango/papaya) sitting over gentle hearth smoke. At 53% ABV it’s vivid but not aggressive, perfect for tasters who want nuance with their peat.
Why I recommend it: It’s Bowmore’s fruit-forward elegance without leaning too sweet. Indie bottlings like this often showcase a specific cask voice you don’t always see in the core range.
Best for: Discovering Bowmore’s fruit-forward, coastal elegance outside distillery bottlings.
SHOP NOW: £184.95
(Brand info: Decadent Drinks / Decadent Drams)
Related reading: What is an Independent Bottler
4) Caol Ila 2007 17 Year Old RMW Oloroso Butt #3 (52%) – sherry-smoke harmony
A Royal Mile Whiskies exclusive from a single Oloroso butt, this 17-year Caol Ila threads brine and lemon through walnut, cocoa, and dark dried fruit. The peat is clean and coastal as ever, but the sherry cask layers in depth and a plush mid-palate. At 52% ABV it’s composed, not fiery.
Why I recommend it: Caol Ila’s precision plus Oloroso’s warmth is catnip if you love structure. It keeps Islay’s classic character while adding winter dessert richness.
Best for: Drinkers who want Islay precision plus sherry richness in one glass.
SHOP NOW: £115
(Brand info: Caol Ila / Royal Mile Whiskies Exclusive)
Related reading: Difference between port and sherry casks
5) Ardmore 2016 8 Year Old Adelphi #1052 (59.7%) – Highland peat with punch
From the Highlands, Ardmore brings a different peat dialect: BBQ smoke, heather, honeyed malt and bright citrus. This Adelphi single cask amps it up at near 60% ABV, robust and mouth-filling but surprisingly defined, with a long, gently ashy finish.
Why I recommend it: It’s a brilliant “contrast” bottle. After Laphroaig’s iodine and brine, Ardmore shows peat can be grilled lemon and heather honey instead of seaweed and sap.
Best for: Cask-strength fans who want peat with heather-honey lift rather than heavy iodine.
SHOP NOW: £68.95
Why these five?
Range & learning value: Together they map peat’s spectrum –
- Medicinal & mature: Laphroaig 18 (calm, integrated smoke)
- Silk-smoke classic: Lagavulin 16 (dried fruit, incense)
- Tropical-coastal indie: Bowmore 2011 Decadent Drams (fruit + hearth)
- Sherry-smoke: Caol Ila 2007 RMW Oloroso #3 (brine + cocoa/raisin)
- Highland power: Ardmore 2016 Adelphi (BBQ, heather, citrus)
Why I chose them: They’re findable, they teach different peat dialects, and each rewards a tweak of water. You’ll feel how age, cask type, and bottling strength move the same core element (peat) in distinct, delicious directions.
