Bourbon

Whiskey Review Round Up: New Deal Distiller’s Reserve

We review three straight whiskeys that make up part of New Deal Distillery's Distillers Reserve series: Reserve Rye, Reserve Bourbon, and Reserve Wheat.

OVERALL RATING

7
Like Conversation

Tasting Notes

About:

Straight rye distilled by New Deal and aged for more than three years in new, charred American oak barrels. Bottled at 80 proof and sold for a recommended price of about $40 per 750mL bottle. Straight bourbon distilled by New Deal and aged for more than three years in new, charred American oak barrels. Bottled at 80 proof and sold for a recommended price of about $40 per 750mL bottle. Straight wheat – and like the others – aged for more than three years in new, charred American oak barrels. Bottled at 80 proof and sold for a recommended price of about $40 per 750mL bottle.
Appearance:
Typical, middle of the road gold color, but with a bit of dispersed residue giving it a slightly cloudy appearance. Another middle-of-the-road gold whiskey, a bit darker than the rye and with more sediment making it appear even cloudier. Very similar in hue to the others, an average gold-colored dram about the same color as the bourbon but the least sediment-clouded of the three.
Nose:
Sweet from the start, opening with honeyed notes of tangerine, plus clove and oak to give it a bit of tang and spice. The honey and tangerine soon weaken to make room for a more subdued toffee, clove, and oak, forming an earthier bouquet. A bit of a tangy and sweet scent at the outset with lemon, grains, and simple syrup as the base and notes of oak and faint flowers giving the bouquet a bit of texture. That mellows into a rich vanilla aroma with notes of oak, orange and a touch of nutmeg. The heaviest-hitting of three on the nose – a sweet and tangy bouquet of sweet vanilla competing with tart lemon and grains. That settles down into a sweet and rich vanilla with notes of pepper and rye-like, and oak.
Palate:
Again hits the tongue with a honey-like sweetness with touches of black pepper and clove tingling the mouth slightly along with a faintly smoky dried fruit flavor. The spicy elements build a bit as the sip sits on the tongue, but never attain anything more than a dull roar. Those flavors fade upon swallowing, leaving a distant toasty-honey residue in the mouth along with a few prickles of spice alongside. Tasting notes: New Deal Distiller’s Reserve Bourbon Vital stats: Straight bourbon distilled by New Deal and aged for more than three years in new, charred American oak barrels. Bottled at 80 proof and sold for a recommended price of about $40 per 750mL bottle. Appearance: Another middle-of-the-road gold whiskey, a bit darker than the rye and with more sediment making it appear even cloudier. Nose: A bit of a tangy and sweet scent at the outset with lemon, grains, and simple syrup as the base and notes of oak and faint flowers giving the bouquet a bit of texture. That mellows into a rich vanilla aroma with notes of oak, orange and a touch of nutmeg. Palate: Starts off like a very mellow caramel – sweet and rich but not overwhelming, with a bit of a burnt, smoky flavor in the background. That caramel remains the base, but it makes room for flavors of corn, oak and pepper to mix in to make the sip smokier and spicier as it remains on the tongue, but again not overwhelmingly so. Swallowing yields a small burst of pepper and then strips those flavors back to a faint and distant brown sugar. The pepper tingles the mouth a bit, but I was generally left with just a sweet, smoky molasses residue on the tongue. Tasting notes: New Deal Distiller’s Reserve Wheat Vital stats: Straight wheat – and like the others – aged for more than three years in new, charred American oak barrels. Bottled at 80 proof and sold for a recommended price of about $40 per 750mL bottle. Appearance: Very similar in hue to the others, an average gold-colored dram about the same color as the bourbon but the least sediment-clouded of the three. Nose: The heaviest-hitting of three on the nose – a sweet and tangy bouquet of sweet vanilla competing with tart lemon and grains. That settles down into a sweet and rich vanilla with notes of pepper and rye-like, and oak. Palate: Hits the tongue like a sweet, rich, and earthy caramel with a stronger than usual smoky elements to the flavor. That gradually develops spicy attributes as it sits on the tongue, especially pepper and nutmeg, building up to be spicier than the others but still not overpowering. Swallowing sends a burst of spice throughout the mouth, which then eases into the sweet, rich caramel from the beginning that coats the tongue and the mouth – occasionally tingling the corners of the mouth with pepper – for another minute or so.
Finish:
Comments:
To sum up New Deal’s Distiller’s Reserve Series, they are all fine: above average but not extraordinary. All three are on the sweeter side of their particular whiskey category. The rye especially lacks the spicy elements of many other ryes making it smooth but relatively bland in comparison. The bourbon is also sweeter, but with enough potency to make it a good starting point if you’re working your way into bourbon. The wheat was actually a bit spicier than I normally encounter among wheats, making it refreshingly complex and the best of the three. Taken as a whole, the Distiller’s Reserve is good but not extraordinary; OK for sipping and probably great for mixing.

Editor’s Note: This whiskey was either bought as a sample by The Whiskey Wash or provided to us as a review sample by the party behind it. Per our editorial policies, this in no way influenced the outcome of this review.

Aaron Knapp

All Posts

Latest On The Whiskey Wash

How To Drink The Famous Grouse

What’s the best way to drink The Famous Grouse: neat, on ice or mixed? Here’s the serve the brand recommends, plus easy cocktails and food pairings.