Weller 12 Year Old has held a special place in my whisky cabinet for years. It was the bottle that made me fall for Weller, and I expected it to come out on top when I tasted it alongside Special Reserve, Antique 107 and Full Proof. Instead, I found myself reconsidering an expression I had once traded away. With these bottles becoming easier to find in the UK, this felt like the right time to ask not just which tastes best, but which is worth buying.
Special Reserve makes a persuasive case for being the everyday Weller. At around £28 to £32 in UK supermarkets, it offers good value at 45% ABV. Spearmint leads both the nose and palate, with butterscotch, caramel and dark chocolate behind it. It is clean, welcoming and enjoyable rather than especially complex, earning a 7 out of 10 from me.
Weller 12, also bottled at 45%, takes those familiar sweet notes somewhere richer. Butterscotch and cream sweets give way to dried fruit, gentle leather and a rounded, drying oak finish. It feels like a dessert trolley soaked in bourbon, and remains a lovely bottle to share. I give it 8.5 out of 10.
Antique 107 was my surprise. My previous bottle struck me as hot and dominated by cinnamon, so I had never understood the enthusiasm for it. This one, bought for about £50 including delivery, changed my mind. At 53.5% ABV, it has a wonderfully oily texture, yet the strength supports rather than overwhelms the flavour. Milk chocolate, peanuts, dried apricot and toasted brown sugar build into a long, mellow finish.
What Weller 12 gains through age, this bottle answers with richness and weight. If I can keep finding Antique 107 at a sensible price and at this quality, it is a superb buy: 9 out of 10.
Full Proof offers the most intense experience of the four, though not necessarily the best sip. Its 57% ABV brings chewy oak, ginger and woody spice, while a striking aroma of blueberries, blackberries and cranberries sits over caramel and vanilla. I have grown to appreciate my store-pick bottle much more than I did when I first opened it, although the roughly £150 I paid still stings. At today’s more typical retail prices, it is easier to recommend. I score it 8.5 out of 10.
Weller 12 has not lost its charm, but Antique 107 has earned the top spot in my lineup. The right bottle can change your mind, even about an old favourite. Which Weller would you put first?
For a closer look at all four bottles and my full tasting, you can watch my video on the Weller lineup.



