Editor’s Note: These whiskies were provided to us as free samples to review by the party behind them. The Whiskey Wash, while appreciative of this, did keep full independent editorial control over this article.Tasting Notes: Rock Town Hickory Smoked Whiskey
Color: Pale gold
Nose: Sweet up front, with honey, butterscotch, and vanilla. Some toast and light smokiness are also there. What dominates, though, is a strong butter note.
Palate: Bread, cherry candy, and more butter transition to wood and cardboard. There’s a vague savoriness in the mid-palate. Light mouthfeel.
Final Score: 79/100
Tasting Notes: Rock Town Single Barrel Reserve Hickory Smoked Whiskey
Color: Light copper
Nose, neat: Vanilla, hard candy, and honey mix with faint smoke
Palate, neat: Buttered toast, nutmeg, and fairly strong, bitter oak, along with a faintly meaty note. Hot and tannic.
Nose, with water: Some of the creamy notes of the regular Hickory Smoked Whiskey come out, though they’re not nearly as strong. I also get salted caramel, apricot, and, again, a slight savoriness.
Palate, with water: Honey and wood are here, along with some light smoke, but underlying everything is a funky, faintly gross combination I can only describe as prosciutto mixed with ink. It’s… odd. Decent body.
Final Score: 78/100
Final Thoughts
Both these whiskeys came across, to me, as something of a weird mess. The Hickory Smoked Whiskey is like drinking melted butter, with fairly little of the smoke flavor the distillery reports. The Single Barrel Reserve is less one-note, but if anything, more of a head-scratcher, with its strange combination of sweetness, umami, and funk. The nice way to describe it, I guess, would be “interesting,” although I don’t care for it personally.
















