American

Garrison Brothers Balmorhea Review

Can a $150+ Texas bourbon really earn its price? We taste Garrison Brothers Balmorhea, a 10-year double-oaked oak and vanilla bomb, to find out.

OVERALL RATING

10
Like Conversation

Tasting Notes

About:

Texas bourbon is known for its big, bold, and intense flavors. Garrison Brothers, Texas’s first legal distillery, has embodied this persona, producing high-quality and intense bourbons that display a character far different from Kentucky offerings. The distillery has, after much hard work, enjoyed wild success, hauling in over 800 spirits awards to date. The distillery also prioritizes charity, donating a small portion of sales to local wildlife preservation, and frequently raising funds for local causes through their nonprofit arm, Good Bourbon for a Good Cause.

The subject of today’s review is the Balmorhea, named after a famous swimming hole in Texas, known for its crystal-clear natural spring water spanning 1.3 acres, and which stays roughly 72-76 degrees year-round.

The whiskey Balmorhea is a double-oaked bourbon, starting its life as Garrison Brothers’ small batch bourbon, but then aged for 4 additional years in different toasted and charred American oak barrels, for a grand total of 10 years in all. The result of the elongated aging process, combined with the highly variable and intense Texas temperatures that accelerate aging and the extraction of wood flavors at nearly double the speed of Kentucky processes, is a oak and vanilla bomb.

At 57.5% ABV, the Balmorhea is “[s]imply put … bourbon candy in a bottle,” describes Master Distiller Donnis Todd. Garrison Brothers gives the dram tasting notes of “[d]ecadent and candy-like with amaretto coffee, sticky buns, frozen fudgesicle bars and pecan brittle. Hints of thick white chocolate.”
Appearance:
Amber and Pinot Noir red.
Nose:
Vanilla coffee, spiced eggnog, cigar box, and burnt sugar, with a hint of chocolate covered cherries.
Palate:
Vanilla pours over candied toffee. Eventually deep rich oak steps up amid maple syrup. Ground coffee beans and earthy tobacco hold the center, covered in thick molasses. Cigars appear toward the end.
Finish:
A spiced ending with black pepper, honey covered charred oak, and campfire tapers off while your lips tingle.
Comments:
Absolutely bursting with flavor, this whiskey is truly a big Texas bourbon. 10 years of charred oak aging in intense and variable heat has produced a focused intensity of the double-oaked category. The dram hits you with overlapping levels of oak, vanilla, coffee, and molasses, yet all of them hold court with one another to combine their efforts, while leaving room for small hints of chocolate and dark fruit.

There are few whiskeys on the market I truly recommend that are over $150, for the simple matter that there is so much good stuff out there for much lower. However, this magnificent whiskey is one to grab if you see it, and savor for as long as you can. Cheers.

Editor’s Note: This whiskey was either bought as a sample by The Whiskey Wash or provided to us as a review sample by the party behind it. Per our editorial policies, this in no way influenced the outcome of this review.

Jeffrey Nitschke

Jeffrey Nitschke is Portland area attorney whose career has dovetailed with a love of fine spirits and cigars. His hometown is rich with microdistilleries, which has afforded him the opportunity to learn the nuances of whiskey tasting and whiskey making. His writing and enthusiasm for the hobby has led to lasting friendships with other whiskey aficionados and connisures across the United States.

All Posts

Latest On The Whiskey Wash