Bourbon

Bourbon Review: Spring Mill Indiana Straight Bourbon Whiskey

We review Spring Mill Indiana Straight Bourbon Whiskey, which comes packaged in a unique ceramic bottle.

OVERALL RATING

7
Like Conversation

Tasting Notes

About:

Indiana straight bourbon with a mash bill of corn, rye and malted barley. Aged for an unspecified amount of time in new, charred American oak barrels, with a portion aged again in an additional set of barrels. Spring Mill is bottled at 45% ABV and sells for about $26 per bottle depending on location.
Appearance:
Spring Mill Bourbon is unusual first off in that it comes in a plain ceramic bottle with naught but the name and distiller in blue and a red label across the bottom. The design is a bit plain and austere, but still appealing in its simplicity – though the bottle is substantially heavier than a typical bottle. Poured into a glass, the whiskey is a touch toward the redder, coppery side of whiskey.
Nose:
Right from the start, Spring Mill Bourbon hits a nice a balance of flavors that reminded me of a citrus tart: the sweetness of caramelized sugar at first, followed by a tangy tangerine. After a few moments, the nasal passages get a punch of spicy ginger with a touch of nutmeg evening out the mix.
Palate:
As in the nose, the first few drops hit the tongue with the sweetness of a thick, rich caramel. That flavor seems to get richer, creamier, and oakier as it sits on the tongue for a moment before it starts to take on spicy notes – this time dominated by black pepper and cloves instead of ginger. Those spicy notes build relentlessly into a moderate burn as it lingers in the mouth. Swallowing sends a moderate wave of those spices washing from the throat to the top of the mouth before fading into an oaky caramel essence throughout with a touch of black tea in the background, punctuated with a few flares of clove for the next minute or so. However, the sooner the swallow, the sweeter and more subdued the flavor is overall.
Finish:
Comments:
Much like how I described the bottle of Spring Mill Bourbon, I found the bottle’s contents pleasant but largely plain and unobjectionable. While I appreciated the moments where this bourbon achieved subtle flavor combinations, those were typically between swings from richly sweet to harshly spicy. However, I give it points for those subtle moments and for being a pleasant dram to sip or mix. rnrnAt about $26 per bottle, I think this bourbon is good a choice within that price point and a far better experience than many others at that same price range.

Editor’s Note: This whiskey was either bought as a sample by The Whiskey Wash or provided to us as a review sample by the party behind it. Per our editorial policies, this in no way influenced the outcome of this review.

Aaron Knapp

All Posts

Latest On The Whiskey Wash