Why I Scored Bunnahabhain 18 Year Old A Rare 90 Points

Is Bunnahabhain 18 worth its steep price? Discover why its sherried fruit, chocolate and coastal salt earned this Scotch a rare 90-point score.
Follow The Whiskey Wash on Google News

Follow The Whiskey Wash on Google News to get our latest reviews and guides delivered straight to your feed.

Like Conversation
reading time
Why I Scored Bunnahabhain 18 Year Old A Rare 90 Points
Credit: Bunnahabhain Distillery

It has been years since I last reviewed the Bunnahabhain 18, so I expected a familiar whisky when I opened this bottle. Instead, I found myself taken aback by its richness. Bottled at 46.3%, this is a deeply sherried, beautifully balanced 18-year-old that stands above most I’ve tasted recently. The question is whether it’s good enough to justify a price that gave me pause.

The first surprise is the nose. I remembered a whisky that seemed to balance bourbon-cask and European oak influences, but this bottle comes across as thoroughly sherry-led. Dried cherries and figs arrive with an unmistakable rush of salt. It is briny without sacrificing sweetness, almost like a dessert served by the sea. There is virtually no peat here. The contrast between rich fruit and that pronounced saltiness gives the aroma its character.

The palate is where the whisky becomes an absolute stunner. Think molten chocolate cake with cherries on top, followed by dates, figs and a little nuttiness without the bitterness I associate with walnuts. The texture is oily and mouth-coating, and the sweetness never becomes cloying because the salt keeps cutting through it. A note of cooked-down cherries, closer to compote than syrup, carries into a long finish alongside the chocolate and dried fruit. There is plenty going on, but the flavours feel integrated rather than crowded.

Price is my only real objection. I bought this bottle on sale for about CA$200 before tax and shipping, and I generally prefer to spend closer to CA$150 or less on an 18-year-old Scotch. The Old Pulteney 18, for example, costs less and is a whisky I enjoy enough to keep stocked. Even so, I prefer this Bunnahabhain. It has the depth and finish to make that higher price feel earned, although I would still look for a deal if one is available.

I don’t give many core-range whiskies a 90, but that is my score for the Bunnahabhain 18. Its combination of sherried fruit, chocolate, coastal salt, and lasting texture makes it a definite buy for me, and I may need a backup bottle. If you’ve tried it, does the quality justify the price for you?

For a closer look at the whisky and my full tasting, watch my video.

Whisky In The 6

Robert De Santis is a professional whisky reviewer with ten years of experience in the field. Over the last decade, Rob’s reviews can be found primarily on the YouTube channel Whisky in the 6. The 6 in the title pays homage to Rob’s roots, born and raised in Toronto. Rob is also the Co-host of The Whisky Rant Podcast, where he’s had the privilege of interview Whisky Royalty like Billy Walker, Richard Urquhart and Ralfy Mitchell.

All Posts