What’s the best whiskey for a Manhattan? The cocktail is traditionally made with rye, but can bourbon compete and hold its own against the vermouth and bitters? Let’s find out.
We had a clear winner in this tasting, and every whiskey was ranked on how it performed in the cocktail, rather than as a neat pour.
To keep things fair, we used the same recipe and method throughout: 50ml of whiskey, 25ml of Cocchi Torino sweet vermouth, and two dashes of orange bitters. Each cocktail was stirred over cubed ice and double-strained into a chilled coupe glass.
1. Rittenhouse Rye 100 Proof, 50%, $21 / £36
A $20 bottle of 100-proof rye is all you need to make a fabulous Manhattan at home or behind the bar.
This shouldn’t come as a surprise. Rittenhouse has always been an excellent rye for sipping or mixing, but this test really showed what it can do.
The finished cocktail was full of soft, warming oak spice and orange bitters. The combination of rye and vermouth brought out wonderful aromas of sweet cherries, strawberries, fresh mint, and a little tickle of spice.
The palate was incredibly moreish, with more of those cherry and mint notes alongside the gentle bitterness of the sweet vermouth. There were even some chocolate notes emerging from the combination.
A truly wonderful cocktail experience.
2. Wild Turkey 101, 50.5%, $18 / £25
I’m sorry. I know I talk about Wild Turkey 101 all the time on this website, but here’s yet another reason to love it.
Not only does this bourbon work brilliantly in an Old Fashioned, but it also makes a powerful Manhattan.
The brown sugar notes and rye spice are emphasized beautifully. Underneath, you’ll find cherry, mint, sweet tobacco, and caraway seeds. Everything comes together in a wonderfully balanced cocktail, with the bourbon, vermouth, dilution, and sharp edge of the bitters all working in harmony.
The orange bitters help bring out the bourbon’s brown sugar and rye spice, while the sweetness of the new oak draws more red fruit and earthy notes from the vermouth.
Simply wonderful. An excellent bourbon for a Manhattan.
3. Elijah Craig Small Batch, 47%, $23 / £39
This one shouldn’t have been a surprise. Elijah Craig is a great bourbon, and I’ve managed to secure a few bottles of the older release to experiment with.
The resulting Manhattan was full of toasted oak, with a noticeably sweeter overall profile. The caramel notes really took me by surprise, alongside plenty of cooked red fruits, including strawberries and cranberries. There was also a touch of damp oak on the nose.
On the palate, gentle spice from the bourbon and oak came through, while the vermouth softened everything with notes of cassia, ginger, and dried citrus peel.
Elijah Craig makes an excellent Manhattan. I wish I’d had a bottle of Elijah Craig Rye on hand to compare, but the bourbon certainly delivered.
4. Bulleit Rye, 45%, $24 / £28
This one comes with a warning. If you’re not a fan of intense spice, I wouldn’t recommend using Bulleit Rye in your next Manhattan. However, the way it delivered spice over sweetness was a welcome surprise.
Bulleit Rye brought out black pepper, cinnamon, nutmeg, and the earthier side of baking spices. Its 95% rye mash bill can divide opinion, but it made for a particularly interesting cocktail. This is a Manhattan that challenges your palate rather than simply delivering sweetness.
In some ways, it’s not that different from drinking Bulleit Rye neat. It’s punchy, powerful, and stands out from the crowd.
Some of you will be pleased to hear that the dill pickle and coriander notes were missing from the finished cocktail. Even so, it carved out its own identity among the sweeter Manhattans in this tasting.
5. WhistlePig 10 Year Old Rye, 50%, $65 / £83
This had flavor, but ultimately felt a little lackluster. WhistlePig has never been a favorite rye producer of mine, largely because I’ve struggled to justify the price.
In the Manhattan, it delivered some pleasant toffee and mint aromas. Unfortunately, once it reached the palate, I felt the vermouth was doing most of the talking.
To be fair, my bottle of WhistlePig has been open for nearly six years, so this wasn’t exactly a fresh bottle.
The finish was fine, but nothing to write home about, particularly after tasting the other cocktails on this list.
It goes to show that an expensive whiskey doesn’t necessarily make a better cocktail.
6. Basil Hayden Bourbon, 40%, $29 / £44
This was the biggest disappointment of the tasting.
I’ve sold cases of Basil Hayden to customers who enjoyed it as a neat pour, but in a cocktail, it really struggles to make an impression.
At 40% ABV, it simply doesn’t have the strength or intensity to carry its flavors through the vermouth, bitters, and dilution.
There were a few redeeming qualities. The nose had a welcome Mars bar-like aroma, with nougat, chocolate, and some red fruit in the background. Unfortunately, the palate was thin and thoroughly underwhelming.
Basil Hayden isn’t necessarily marketed as a cocktail whiskey, but at this price, I’m not entirely convinced it offers enough value as a neat sipper, either.
Rye vs. Bourbon: Which Makes The Better Manhattan?
Rye took the top spot, but bourbon claimed second and third place, proving that both styles can make an excellent Manhattan. Unfortunately, bourbon also finished last.
The biggest takeaway from this tasting is that the individual whiskey matters more than whether it’s rye or bourbon. You want something with enough flavor, spice, and character to stand up to the vermouth, bitters, and dilution.
When making cocktails at home, don’t be afraid to experiment. You never know which bottle might surprise you.
There’s also something to be said about price. Last year, I had the chance to try what was billed as “the most expensive cocktail” at an event. The event itself was incredible, but the cocktail was the only disappointment. It was made with a £3,000 bottle of whiskey, and the result was fine. Just fine.
As this tasting showed, you don’t need to spend a fortune to make a great Manhattan. Sometimes a $20 bottle of rye is all you need.












