Bourbon is one of the most versatile spirits you can keep at home. It mixes beautifully, it is widely available, and you do not need to spend a fortune to find a bottle that works well in cocktails.
The best cocktails start with the right bourbon. A Whiskey Sour needs a bold whiskey that can cut through citrus. An Old Fashioned deserves a spirit with enough character to stand on its own. Even the easiest highballs taste better when the base spirit has the right mix of sweetness, spice, and strength.
All of the bourbons in this list cost between $20 and $50. They are accessible, reliable, and proven behind the bar. Some are well-known classics, while others are more under the radar. Each one has been chosen because it pairs perfectly with a specific cocktail.
Here are six bourbon and cocktail pairings that show just how good whiskey cocktails can be.
Must Read Stories
1. Whiskey Sour – Wild Turkey 101
The Whiskey Sour is one of the most refreshing bourbon cocktails. It blends lemon juice, sugar, and bourbon into a drink that is sharp, smooth, and balanced. Some recipes add egg white for a creamy texture (I love the addition of egg whites, but they are optional), but the star of the show is always the bourbon.
You want a whiskey that does not disappear behind the citrus. Wild Turkey 101 is ideal. Bottled at 101 proof, it has enough strength to cut through the acidity of the fresh lemon. Its rye-heavy mash bill adds a spicy backbone, while notes of caramel and vanilla bring depth to the sweetness.
Wild Turkey 101 is also affordable, usually around $25, and easy to find. That makes it one of the best bourbons for a Whiskey Sour, whether you are mixing for friends or just making a quick drink at home.
2. Old Fashioned – Old Forester 100 Proof
The Old Fashioned is about as simple as cocktails get, and an absolute classic. Bourbon, sugar, bitters, and an orange twist. Because there is nowhere to hide, the drink depends on the quality of the whiskey.
Old Forester 100 Proof is a great choice. Bottled at 50% ABV, it delivers enough strength to stay bold even when stirred with ice. Its flavor profile is rich, with notes of cherry, vanilla, and baking spice that complement the bitters and citrus garnish.
Priced around $25 to $30, Old Forester 100 Proof offers great value. It has a history that dates back to 1870, which gives it the kind of authenticity bartenders love. If you want alternatives, Elijah Craig Small Batch and Wild Turkey 101 also make excellent Old Fashioneds.
3. Whiskey Smash – Buffalo Trace
The Whiskey Smash is a bright, refreshing cocktail. It combines fresh mint, lemon wedges, sugar, and bourbon. Think of it as a cross between a Whiskey Sour and a Mint Julep.
For this drink, you want a bourbon that is smooth and balanced. Buffalo Trace fits perfectly. At 90 proof, it is gentle enough to let the citrus and mint shine, but it still has enough depth to remind you that it is a bourbon cocktail. Its caramel and vanilla notes blend naturally with the sweetness, while subtle spice adds structure.
Buffalo Trace is also a great crowd-pleaser. It is approachable for new bourbon drinkers but still respected by enthusiasts. Usually priced around $25-$30, it works as well in cocktails as it does neat.
If you like a softer profile, Larceny Bourbon is another excellent choice. Its wheated mash bill adds a gentle sweetness that pairs well with mint and lemon.
The Whiskey Smash is meant to be light and lively. With Buffalo Trace as the base, it strikes the perfect balance.
4. Kentucky Mule – Woodford Reserve
The Kentucky Mule is a simple but lively cocktail. It swaps vodka for bourbon in the classic Moscow Mule recipe, combining ginger beer, lime juice, and a garnish of fresh mint. The result is spicy, zesty, and refreshing.
Woodford Reserve is an ideal bourbon for this drink. At just over 90 proof, it has a smooth profile with notes of vanilla, honey, and gentle spice. Those flavors balance the heat of the ginger beer and the sharpness of lime. The mint garnish ties everything together.
Woodford Reserve also has heritage on its side. It is the presenting sponsor of the Kentucky Derby, an event where bourbon cocktails (particularly the Kentucky Mule) are part of the tradition. That connection makes it an especially fitting choice for a Kentucky Mule.
This is also one of the easiest whiskey cocktails to make at home. With Woodford Reserve as the base, you get a Mule that is smooth, balanced, and unmistakably Kentucky. And all of that for around $30-$40.
5. Manhattan – New Riff Bottled-in-Bond
The Manhattan is a classic stirred cocktail that pairs whiskey with sweet vermouth and bitters. Traditionally made with rye, it also works beautifully with a bold bourbon.
New Riff Bottled-in-Bond is a great choice. This Kentucky distillery is relatively new, but its bourbon has already built a strong reputation. Bottled at 100 proof and made with a high-rye mash bill, it delivers rich fruit, caramel, and spice. Those flavors stand up to the sweetness of vermouth and the aromatics of bitters, making it an excellent Manhattan base.
At around $40-$50, New Riff is a little harder to find than mass-market bottles, but that adds to its appeal. It gives your cocktail something distinctive and shows off a modern craft approach to bourbon.
If New Riff is not available, other high-rye bourbons like Old Grand-Dad Bonded or Four Roses Small Batch also shine in a Manhattan.
This cocktail deserves a bourbon with structure and personality. New Riff Bottled-in-Bond brings both, making your Manhattan stand out.
6. Bourbon Highball – Maker’s Mark
Sometimes the best cocktail is the simplest one. The Bourbon Highball mixes bourbon with a fizzy partner like ginger ale, ginger beer, or club soda. Served over ice, it is crisp, refreshing, and effortless.
Maker’s Mark is a perfect fit. This wheated bourbon is known for its mellow profile, with soft caramel and vanilla notes that pair smoothly with a mixer. At 90 proof, it has just enough strength to keep the drink lively without being overpowering.
The Whiskey Ginger is a popular variation of the Highball. Maker’s Mark blends seamlessly with ginger ale, creating a drink that is sweet, spicy, and easy to enjoy. Four Roses Bourbon is another excellent option if you want something slightly fruitier.
The Bourbon Highball is as easy as it gets, and tastes incredible with the addition of Maker’s Mark. You can usually find it for around $25-$40.
Happy Mixing
You do not need expensive bottles to make great bourbon cocktails. Each of these bourbons costs between $20 and $50 and brings the right mix of flavor and strength to its perfect serve. From classics like Wild Turkey 101 in a Whiskey Sour to the craft edge of New Riff in a Manhattan, there is something here for every taste.
Which bourbon cocktails do you enjoy most? Share your favorites and let us know what you are mixing.
