When it comes to single malt scotch, there’s something special about a well-made 12 year old. It’s the sweet spot between youth and maturity, often offering complexity and balance without the price tag of older bottlings. From everyday pours to iconic classics, a good 12-year-old whisky can set the tone for an entire distillery’s range.
At The Whiskey Wash, we’ve tasted dozens of 12 year old scotches in 2025, and these three stood out. Whether it’s the rich sherry influence of Macallan, the rustic Highland character of Deanston, or the honeyed smoothness of Aberfeldy, each of these bottles brings something distinctive to the table.
Below, we’ve highlighted what makes each one worth your time, with quotes from our full reviews and links to dive deeper if something catches your eye.
Deanston 12 Year Old: A Quirky Highlander with Breakfast Charm
At 46.3% ABV and unchill-filtered, Deanston 12 Year Old brings a robust Highland identity with a twist. While it might not be the first dram you’d hand a newcomer, its character is undeniably memorable. Sweet, spicy, and ever so slightly eccentric.
A core part of Deanston’s range since the 1970s and reimagined in 2012, this expression wears its age lightly but delivers a surprisingly layered experience. Expect a nose of sour apples and wax, a palate that swings into syrupy breakfast territory, and a finish with a curious jalapeño-like kick.
Davis Gonnella summed up the delicious palate, saying: “McDonalds apple pies, Tuc biscuits and canned syrup fruits… sweet and cereal notes really sit this one in the breakfast dram category.”
With its pudding-heavy flavors and spicy close, this one lingers longer than expected, and punches above its 12-year label. For those after something slightly off the mainstream path (without going full peat), Deanston 12 is a bottle worth exploring.
Read our full review of Deanston 12 Year Old here.
Signup now to make sure you don't miss out on the latest whiskey news and deals.
By Signing up, you accept and agree to our Terms of Services and you acknowledge our Privacy Statement. The Whiskey Wash is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
The Macallan 12 Year Old Sherry Oak: A Benchmark in Sherry Maturation
Few bottles carry the same global recognition as Macallan 12 Year Old Sherry Oak. First released under Macallan’s own label in 1984, this expression has become synonymous with rich, sherry-matured Scotch and remains a gateway to the brand’s broader portfolio.
At 40% ABV, it’s approachable yet full of character. The nose is textbook sherry: raisins, figs, dates, and dark chocolate, laced with orange oil and soft baking spice. On the palate, it delivers classic fruitcake richness with layers of vanilla, rhubarb, and cocoa powder. The finish continues the theme, bringing in chocolate truffle notes with a subtle, Cognac-like edge.
“You have all of those classic sherry notes again… wrapped up in some wonderful cocoa powder notes at the very back of the palate,” noted Phil Dwyer in his review.
For many whisky drinkers, this is the 12-year-old to beat, an elegant bottle with a deep sense of heritage and an unmistakable sherry signature. Despite a crowded field, Macallan’s icon still holds its own.
Read our full review of The Macallan 12 Year Old Sherry Oak here.
Aberfeldy 12 Year Old: A Smooth Highland Sipper with Substance
Aberfeldy 12 Year Old might not shout for attention, but its quiet confidence makes it one of the most dependable 12-year-olds on the shelf. Bottled at 40% ABV and known as the “Golden Dram,” it leans into Highland charm (fruity, spicy, and mellow) with a buttery texture that makes it effortlessly drinkable.
The nose opens with dried apricot, red apple, and a dusting of clove spice. The palate is soft and rounded, blending apple and citrus with a nutty salinity and just enough heat to keep things interesting. Spice builds gradually with cinnamon and nutmeg, but it never overwhelms the easygoing character.
John Dover was impressed with the dependability of the Aberfeldy 12 Year Old, saying: “Sometimes all you want is a smooth sipper with enough character to bring you back, dram after dram.”
It’s approachable without being boring, and balanced without feeling engineered. For those new to single malts, or anyone after a reliable weekday pour, Aberfeldy 12 earns its place as a staple.
Read our full review of Aberfeldy 12 Year Old here.
Latest On The Whiskey Wash
