Johnnie Walker Black Label is one of the most popular Johnnie Walker whiskies for its balance of sweetness and smoke, but what if you want something more from the smoke? In that case, there are two ways to go.
Johnnie Walker Double Black amps up the intensity of the peat smoke, using smoky whiskies from the west coast of Scotland alongside whiskies matured in heavily charred oak casks. Johnnie Walker Green Label, the only blended malt in the core range, combines 15-year-old single malts for freshness, vibrancy, and a more complex smoky finish.
So, which bottle should you choose? I put Double Black and Green Label head-to-head to find out which is the better value and what each smoky approach has to offer drinkers.
Signup now to make sure you don't miss out on the latest whiskey news and deals.
By Signing up, you accept and agree to our Terms of Services and you acknowledge our Privacy Statement. The Whiskey Wash is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Signup now to make sure you don't miss out on the latest whiskey news and deals.
By Signing up, you accept and agree to our Terms of Services and you acknowledge our Privacy Statement. The Whiskey Wash is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Johnnie Walker Double Black & Green Label At A Glance
If smoke is what you enjoy most, Double Black is the more obvious pick of the two. It’s a bold, sweet, peaty blend with plenty of charred oak, barbecue smoke, and vanilla, and it’s also the cheaper bottle, particularly in the US.
Trending Content
Green Label takes a gentler approach. It’s built around Talisker, Caol Ila, Cragganmore, and Linkwood, so you get pepper and smoke from the island malts alongside orchard fruit and fresh, green notes from Speyside, with most of the smoke saved for the finish.
Which one comes out on top really depends on how much smoke you want and how you like to drink your whisky, so let’s look at what goes into each bottle.
Every Kirkland Bourbon Ranked, From Worst to Best
READ THE STORYBlended Scotch vs Blended Malt
Double Black and Green Label belong to two different categories of Scotch whisky. Double Black is a blended Scotch, which means it combines single malt whisky with single grain whisky. Green Label is a blended malt, so it’s made only from single malts from two or more distilleries, with no grain whisky at all.
The same regulations retired the old terms “vatted malt” and “pure malt,” which is why Green Label started life as Johnnie Walker Pure Malt in 1997 before it was renamed in 2004.
What’s in Each Bottle
Johnnie Walker Double Black
Double Black was first released in global travel retail in January 2010 and went on general sale in 2011.
Johnnie Walker doesn’t name the distilleries in the blend, but it describes Double Black as a mix of whiskies matured in heavily charred oak casks and smoky whiskies from the west coast of Scotland and Islay. There is definitely some Caol Ila in there driving the smoke.
Unlike its Black Label sibling, it carries no age statement.
Johnnie Walker Green Label
Every whisky in Johnnie Walker Green Label has spent at least 15 years maturing, and it’s bottled at 43% ABV, a little stronger than Double Black. It’s built around four single malts: Talisker from Skye, Caol Ila from Islay, and Cragganmore and Linkwood from Speyside.
Johnnie Walker Green Label was discontinued in 2012, but made a triumphant return in 2016 following calls from fans to bring the whisky back. We’ve covered the full story of why fans wouldn’t let it die.
How They Taste
Johnnie Walker Double Black
Double Black opens with sweet peat smoke, clove, and a touch of tar, along with raisins, sultanas, and orange zest underneath. The palate is creamy and sweet, with vanilla, caramel, and pepper working alongside plenty of smoke, and the finish is fairly short and dry, with black pepper and cool smoke.
Johnnie Walker suggests adding water to open it up, and the smoke holds its own over ice or in a soda-and-lime highball.
Johnnie Walker Green Label
Green Label is lighter and fresher. When I tasted it for my Naked Malt comparison, I found a floral, herbal nose, and a palate with mint, eucalyptus, black pepper, and salty smoke, though not much weight to the body. Though its liveliness somewhat makes up for this.
You might also pick up cut grass, fresh fruit, and sandalwood, as well as dates, walnut, and bitter chocolate. Most of the smoke comes through on the finish.
It’s at its best neat with a drop of water, though it also makes a lovely highball as long as the soda is fresh.
So, if you’re after smoke above all else, Double Black gives you more of it. Phil Dwyer describes it as “Black Label’s louder, rowdier cousin,” and Whisky Advocate gave it 94 points in its Spring 2026 issue.
Green Label, sometimes referred to as the ‘enthusiast’s choice’, is the one to choose if you’d rather have a range of flavors with the smoke sitting further in the background.
The Price
In the UK, Double Black sells for between about £29 and £40, with the lower prices usually coming from supermarket offers. Green Label costs between about £43 and £50, so you’re typically paying around £10 to £14 more for it.
In the US, Double Black sells for around $33 to $45, and Green Label for around $44 to $60, which works out at roughly $11 to $15 extra.
For a 15-year-old Scotch made entirely from single malts, Green Label is pretty fairly priced, and our reviewer Pete “Jeff Whisky” Jeffery said it offers “possibly the best value” in the core Johnnie Walker range.
Double Black is still the cheaper of the two, though, and if you catch it on offer, the difference is big enough to make it an easy choice for a weeknight bottle.
The Bottom Line
Overall, I think Green Label is the better whisky, and not simply because it’s older. It has more going on, from the fresh, herbal notes to the fruit and the peppery smoke on the finish. With only around £10 to £14, or $11 to $15, between the two bottles, the extra cost is easy to justify.
Double Black still has a lot going for it, though. It’s the smokier of the two and the better value if peat is what you’re after. It also holds up well over ice or in a highball, where Green Label’s lighter notes can get lost.
So, if you want as much smoke as possible for your money, choose Double Black. If you’d rather have a whisky with more depth to enjoy neat, Green Label is worth the extra.
