Whether you’re buying a gift, treating yourself, or just curious about which of these iconic blends deserves your attention, this article breaks down how they compare on taste, price, and critical acclaim.
Read on, then let us know which you’d choose.
The Prestige Behind the Labels
Johnnie Walker Blue Label and Royal Salute 21 Year Old Signature Blend are two of the most recognizable names in luxury whisky. But their stories, and what they promise in the glass, are quite different.
Royal Salute was launched in 1953 by Chivas Brothers to mark Queen Elizabeth II’s coronation. Every drop in the blend has spent at least 21 years in oak casks, and it’s bottled in an ornate ceramic flagon that adds to its regal image. It’s a whisky that trades on tradition, time, and a sense of heritage.
Johnnie Walker Blue Label, on the other hand, carries no age statement but is built around rarity. The brand claims that only one in 10,000 casks is good enough to make the cut. It’s positioned as the ultimate Johnnie Walker blend, with global recognition and prestige built on exclusivity and smoothness.
Both bottles are made to impress. But while Royal Salute leans on age and depth, Blue Label makes its case with selection and brand power.
How They’re Made
While both whiskies aim for complexity and balance, their production methods reflect different philosophies.
Royal Salute 21 Year Old is a traditional age-stated blend. Every component has been matured for a minimum of 21 years, with Strathisla often considered the heart of the blend. The whisky is crafted by Chivas Brothers’ blending team, led by Master Blender Sandy Hyslop, who selects from a wide range of well-aged malt and grain whiskies to maintain a consistent profile. The result is layered, rich, and unmistakably Speyside in style, with a touch of subtle smoke.

Johnnie Walker Blue Label, by contrast, is a no-age-statement blend. Diageo doesn’t disclose the specific distilleries used, but it’s widely believed to include malt from Clynelish, Cardhu, and grain whiskies from Port Dundas or Cambus. The key selling point is selection. Only the rarest, most exceptional casks from Diageo’s vast reserves make it into Blue Label. The goal is smoothness and elegance.
Tasting Notes and Flavor
Royal Salute 21 Year Old opens with a nose of honey, vanilla, oak, and soft sherried fruit, with a light wisp of smoke. Mark Bostock for The Whiskey Wash describes it as “very smooth on the palate… initially fruity with flavors of orange, pear and red apple,” followed by cinnamon, oak, and buttery malted toast. The finish is “lingering and slightly drying.” He scores it 8/10, noting that it balances fruit, sherry, and smoke into a “pleasant, easy drinking blended whisky.”
Jason Debly gives a more critical take. He found “wild honey on crunchy toast,” cardamom, mint chocolate, and pepper, but felt the finish was too short for the price. Notably, he observed that “oxygen is not a friend of this scotch”. He added that “Johnnie Walker Blue Label is such a whisky and in this sense is clearly superior to Royal Salute.”
Johnnie Walker Blue Label is known for its softness and polish. Bostock describes a nose of cherry blossom, oak, vanilla, honey, and orange peel. The palate brings “tropical citrus fruit,” milk chocolate, apple, and a faint saltiness, finishing with dry oak, cinnamon, white pepper, and lingering orange. He calls it “a smooth and well-balanced whisky” that’s easy drinking, though possibly underwhelming for seasoned single malt fans.
Nick Leghorn of Thirty One Whiskey adds another layer, describing it as “velvety smooth,” with flavors of brown sugar, vanilla buttercream, sourdough bread, dark chocolate, and baking spices. He gives it four out of five stars, praising its buttery texture and restrained complexity.
Pricing and Value
In terms of cost, Royal Salute 21 Year Old is generally more affordable. It typically retails for around $150 in the US and £120–£130 in the UK, depending on the seller. For a blend made entirely of whiskies aged at least 21 years, many consider it a fair price, especially given the ornate ceramic flagon and royal branding.
Johnnie Walker Blue Label, by contrast, commands a higher price, often $180–$220 in the US and £150–£180 in the UK. While it lacks an age statement, its premium is built on the claim of rarity and consistency.

If you’re looking for guaranteed age and layered richness, Royal Salute may offer better value. But if your priority is ultimate smoothness and luxury presentation, Blue Label justifies its premium, at least for some.
So Which Is Better?
There’s no single winner. Only what suits your taste.
If you value declared age, richness, and a touch more spice, Royal Salute 21 Year Old offers strong credentials. It’s layered, elegant, and brings the assurance of 21 years in the barrel. It also comes in below Blue Label in price, making it attractive for those who want luxury without stretching their budget.
But if smoothness and consistency matter more, Johnnie Walker Blue Label is hard to beat. It’s refined, subtle, and stays remarkably stable from the first pour to the last. For many, that level of polish justifies the premium.
Ultimately, both are masterfully made and have their place. One is traditional, the other modern. One is rich and regal, the other suave and subtle.
Tried them both? Tell us which one you’d choose in the comments.






