Every year, the whisky world buzzes with ‘Whisky of the Year’ lists. My own selection process is, shall we say, very scientific, mildly emotional and sometimes a bit messy. This year, however, I wanted my winner to represent something more than just exceptional flavour. It had to be honest and accessible, a bottle that proves fantastic Scotch doesn’t require a bankrupting price tag. It needed to be a whisky for everyone.
The journey to the top spot was crowded with brilliant contenders. An exceptional Ardnamurchan was ultimately held back by its premium price. A spectacular Compass Box blend was disqualified because it was a review sample, and I have a strict rule about using my own money for the top pick. Even a beloved Benromach Peat Smoke, a personal go-to, was set aside to avoid any perception of bias towards a brand I admire so much.
So, the crown this year goes to a bottle I’ve purchased three times: the Ledaig Sinclair Series from Tobermory Distillery. Finished in Rioja casks, it’s a masterclass in balance. You get a peppery, coastal peat that clashes beautifully with dark red berries, creating a profile that’s almost like a fruit meringue dessert thrown onto a beach bonfire. It is smoky, fruity, and deeply interesting. Most importantly, it delivers fantastic bang for your buck as a non-age-statement single malt you can find in a supermarket, often for under £40, and presented at 46.3% ABV, fully natural. It just ticks every box.
Quick whisky question
Single malt is everywhere, but what does it mean? We want to know what the word “single” means to you. Three quick questions, under a minute.
This choice is also a statement. While we have seen so many brands creep up their prices, Tobermory is a distillery that is still doing it right. They are putting high quality, honest whisky on the shelf at a price that does not punish enthusiasts. For me, that is exactly what the whisky world needs right now: integrity in the bottle and on the price tag.
Ultimately, my whisky of the year had to be a bottle I could recommend to anyone, regardless of their budget or stage in their journey. The Ledaig Sinclair is accessible, affordable, and absolutely awesome; it simply overdelivers on every front. But this is just my take, so I have to ask: what bottle truly won you over this year?
For a more detailed breakdown and to see all the runners-up for yourself, watch my YouTube video.
Latest On The Whiskey Wash
