Phil Dwyer, whisky YouTuber and former manager of The Whisky Shop Manchester, recently reviewed two bottles of Red Label: one from the 1970s and one from today. The difference, he says, is night and day.
A Global Blend From the Beginning
Red Label launched in 1909 as part of a rebrand by the Walker family. Previously sold as “Special Old Highland,” it was renamed and redesigned for international markets. The slanted red label and “Striding Man” logo became iconic symbols of consistency and global reach.
By the 1920s, Johnnie Walker was already available in 120 countries. Red Label was designed to be bold, approachable, and easy to mix. An ideal scotch for a growing world of highballs and cocktails.
It’s blended from up to 35 malt and grain whiskies, including well-known distilleries like Cardhu and Talisker, to deliver a spicy, slightly smoky profile that holds up in mixed drinks.
The global appeal of the blend is not lost on Phil, who wrote: “While connoisseurs may seek out older, rarer blends, Red Label is the blend that built the brand’s global reputation. It represents movement, accessibility, and the idea that good whisky doesn’t have to be exclusive.”
Phil Dwyer Reviews a 1970s Bottle of Red Label
On the nose, he describes it as “soft and sweet, not what I expected at all. Vanilla and buttercream, sweet green apple, mandarin, lillet blanc, caramel sauce, brandy, raisin, milk chocolate.”
The palate, Phil says, was “Unusual. Starts off very sweet and then it just falls away, leads very strongly with aperol, campari, little peat smoke, ashy, orange oil, brown sugar, red vermouth, almost Negroni-like bitterness across the board.”
He adds that the finish is “light and gently smoky” with “soft fruit elements of orange and sharp raspberry.”
His overall impression is surprisingly positive: “One of the most interesting bottles of Johnnie Walker I’ve ever tried.”
This aligns with what many long-time drinkers have observed. That older blends, even mass-market ones, often show more depth and character than their modern equivalents, especially when higher proportions of aged malt whisky were used.
The Modern Red Label Falls Short
In his review of the current Red Label, Dwyer is more restrained. He notes that the nose is “a little heavier on the grain whisky” and that it shows “sweetness from the grain and some of the younger Highland and Speyside malts.” There’s a “very distantly smoky” note, which he speculates might come from Caol Ila or Talisker.
On the palate, he says, “You do taste the youthful side of it… it’s gristy, malty and a little short when it comes to those flavors sticking around.” The smoke plays only a small part. The finish is “relatively short… a little gristy and malty again with that vegetal note making a brief appearance.
Dwyer sums it up plainly: “It’s a very simple, price-driven whisky in the most global way possible… I’m not a fan of it when compared to Black Label, I’d always pay the extra to get that instead.”
Still, he doesn’t write it off entirely. “When you’re strapped for cash or just wanting a cheaper whisky to put into mixed drinks, this is an ideal candidate… It’s never expensive, it’s always available, the look and branding of it is so iconic across the globe.”
Built to Be Mixed and Shared
The key to Red Label’s success lies in its consistency and mixability. Its bright spice and faint smoke make it ideal for cocktails or a classic scotch and soda.
As Whisky Advocate notes, Red Label is a “long-established blend” that “just blends in”. It is reliable, affordable, and hard to get wrong. It may not challenge the palate, but it isn’t supposed to.
In 2021, Johnnie Walker Master Blender Jim Beveridge noted that “Red Label is more for high-energy occasions with lots of ice or a mixer.”
So, Has It Ever Been Drinkable?
Yes, especially in the past, if you believe the reviews. The 1970s bottling shows what Red Label used to offer: a balanced, flavorful introduction to scotch whisky with enough malt presence to enjoy neat. Even today, when judged on the right terms, it remains drinkable, just not remarkable.
Final Thoughts: Yes, It’s Drinkable, If You Know What to Expect
So, has Johnnie Walker Red Label ever been drinkable? Absolutely. Especially in the past. And even today, when used as intended, it holds up as one of the best-value mixing whiskies on the planet.
Phil Dwyer puts it best: Red Label is “a no-brainer when it comes to wanting something to pour and just not think about.”
It may not thrill connoisseurs, but it continues to introduce millions of people to scotch whisky. And in the end, that’s something worth raising a glass to.






