Scotch

Review: Lochlea Cask Strength Batch 2 5 Year Old

$81

OVERALL
RATING

9

Review: Lochlea Cask Strength Batch 2 5 Year Old

If you enjoy the flavors of Lochlea Cask Strength Batch 2 or other Lochlea expressions, it can certainly be a great introduction to scotch.
Like Conversation

Tasting Notes:

About:
Lochlea’s Cask Strength Batch 2 is a single malt scotch whisky from this independent, family-owned farm and distillery. It’s a limited edition annual release, and this batch is drawn from Oloroso, STR and PX casks, bottled at 60% without chill filtration or added colour. Sampled at the presented cask strength, but adding a few drops of water would be entirely allowed.
Appearance:
Dark amber, almost loose-leaf tea, with a red hue. Thick and oily in the glass with prominent legs.
Nose:
Full of dark sherried fruits with raisins, prunes and figs. Further berry notes of cranberries, redcurrants and blackcurrants. Old leather and dark oak, like a well-oiled dining table. A sweet malt character is followed by wood spice.
Palate:
Medium to full mouthfeel. Those dark sherried fruits are again prominent, plenty of raisins, prunes and figs. Red plums and red apple. Dark rich caramel. There is some heat, unsurprising at 60% but, even at this high proof, the alcohol is well integrated.
Finish:
Medium to long finish. Rich sherried fruits continue through from the nose and palate. Spice and a touch of vibrant heat. Sherry sweetness evolves into a savoury malt character towards the finale, but it’s the fruit that lingers longest.
Comments:
An exciting whisky from an emerging, independent, distillery. Heavily sherried packing plenty of fruit. Big, bold and flavoursome.

How Does Lochlea Cask Strength Batch 2 Compare To Other Cask Strength Whiskies?

Given the youthfulness of both the whisky and the distillery, it wouldn’t be truly fair to compare Lochlea to some of the big hitters of Glenfarclas 105 or Aberlour A’bunadh. But it does hold its own unique position in the whisky world as a very available and almost standalone cask-strength whisky from the Lowlands. Daftmill springs to mind instantly as a ‘hold on a minute’ caveat, but those bottles disappear like you wouldn’t believe.

Kingsbarns does have some cask strength releases, as do their neighbors at Lindores Abbey – but with a rather attractive color to it, and the success of Batch 1, Lochlea seems to be carving out its own little path of barrel-proof power across the lowlands of Scotland.

Signup now to make sure you don't miss out on the latest whiskey news and deals.

By Signing up, you accept and agree to our Terms of Services and you acknowledge our Privacy Statement. The Whiskey Wash is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Plus, with this balance of flavor we’re getting from savory malted barley, rich caramels, and big sherried fruits, perhaps this could actually be compared to some of the bigger names in cask-strength single malt.

Is This A Good Introduction To Scotch Whisky?

Yes and no. Yes, because Lochlea is a newer distillery carving its own path with distinct flavors, and for someone looking to explore scotch whisky, starting with a distillery that’s at the beginning of its journey can be exciting. If you enjoy the flavors of Lochlea Cask Strength Batch 2 or other Lochlea expressions, it can certainly be a great introduction.

However, the ‘no’ comes in when considering that this is a cask-strength whisky. If you’re new to the whisky world, you’ll likely encounter cask-strength whiskies at some point, but I wouldn’t recommend starting with one. Cask-strength whiskies can be intense, with bold and nuanced flavors that can be overwhelming for beginners. It’s worth developing your palate with regular strength whiskies first so that when you do try cask strength, you can truly appreciate its complexities. It’s quite an experience—so be prepared for the ride when you’re ready!

The Best Ways To Enjoy Lochlea Cask Strength Batch 2?

As with all whisky, whatever way you like to enjoy it, go with it. Neat, ice, water, mixed, just drink it how you like. It’s your money.

However, with cask-strength whiskies, I am a huge champion of pouring them, letting them sit for a while in the glass and just smelling them for a long time. As soon as you don’t start to get anything new, have a taste. That first taste will tell you a million different things, after this keep drinking it neat if you like it, or add some water to the last quarter of the pour and see if it changes because it will.

Ed Leigh

Ed Leigh is a recognized authority on independent bottlers and artisan Scotch whisky. In 2019, he founded TopWhiskies.com, a specialist retailer dedicated to promoting these often family-run businesses and showcasing their small-batch releases. Based in London, Ed holds certifications in both wine and spirits from The Wine & Spirit Education Trust.

All Posts
Search
  • Latest News
  • Latest Reviews