Secret Red Flags: How This Whisky Family Fooled the Law and Built a Scotch Empire

Cardhu's Helen Cumming would casually invite tax collectors into her home for tea while simultaneously warning neighboring illegal distillers with a red flag signal.
Like Conversation
reading time

Every bottle of Cardhu whisky tells a hidden story of deception, featuring a woman who outsmarted government officials with nothing but a red flag and remarkable courage.

In the hills of Speyside, Helen Cumming would casually invite tax collectors into her home for tea while simultaneously warning neighboring illegal distillers with a red flag signal. This daring family of whisky rebels didn’t just evade the law, they went on to create Cardhu, now a cornerstone of Johnnie Walker blends worth over $206 million (£150 million) annually in global sales.

While thousands of illicit stills operated throughout Scotland in the early 1800s, the Cummings’ Cardow farm operation stood out for its exceptional quality and Helen’s legendary quick thinking.

The Path to Legality

John and Helen Cumming were used to operating on the fringe. When excisemen came to visit, they did the opposite of most and invited them into their homes.

It’s said that Helen would break down the still, pull it out the back door, and start some good stew to cover the scent of mash. While John kept the excisemen company out front, Helen also snuck away to raise a red flag, warning the neighbors that it was time to pack up their stills.

The Cummings were doing what farmers did in the Highlands—whatever was necessary to survive. The contemporary laws weren’t friendly to small families trying to make a little whisky to prevent their crops from going to waste.

Cardhu distillery
Cardhu Distillery, the Speyside home of Johnnie Walker (image via Diageo)

The Excise Act of 1823 changed everything, making it much easier to go legal. Once given the opportunity to legally produce whisky, the Cummings took advantage. They took out a license for Cardrow (later Cardhu) Distillery in 1824.

Becoming a Leader

The Legacy of an Illicit Distiller

I doubt John and Helen Cumming, two farmers eking out a living with their small still, would ever have imagined articles being written about them 200 years in the future. Their legacy lives on due to their ability to think on their feet, embrace change, and be trailblazers in the whisky industry.

They passed those traits onto their children, who for generations ran one of the lynchpins of Johnnie Walker and DCL (now Diageo) for decades. Now, their legacy continues to be immortalized by a small figure atop every Cardhu bottle: a humble farm woman hoisting a red flag.

Justin Boyer

Justin Boyer is a Member of the Council of Whiskey Masters, a Master of Scotch, a Whiskey Sommelier, and Executive Bourbon Steward. His love of storytelling and history has brought him to the rich stories and deep history of whiskey. He tells his stories through writing and through conducting whiskey tastings, both privately and in local bars and restaurants. Justin prides himself on sharing rare and exciting whiskies with others, building bonds, and spreading the deep joy and connection that whisky provides.

All Posts