Peated Whisky for Beginners: Why Some Whiskies Taste Smoky (& 5 Bottles to Try)

We’ll explain the science behind the smoke and suggest five beginner-friendly bottles to help you begin your journey into peated whisky.

by Mark Littler
April 10, 2025

Mark Littler, owner of The Whiskey Wash and whisky broker and market analyst.

reading time

The distinctive aroma of peat smoke drifting from a glass of whisky is both captivating and, for many newcomers, a little intimidating. With bold, smoky flavors often likened to coal tar, sea brine, or campfire ash, peated whiskies are a world apart. It’s no surprise many beginners approach them with caution.

This guide aims to demystify peat and introduce smoky whiskies in a more approachable way. We’ll explain the science behind the smoke and suggest five beginner-friendly bottles to help you begin your journey into peated whisky.

Signup now to make sure you don't miss out on the latest whiskey news and deals.

By Signing up, you accept and agree to our Terms of Services and you acknowledge our Privacy Statement. The Whiskey Wash is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

What is Peat and How Does it Create a Smoky Flavor?

Peat is ancient plant matter – mosses, grasses, and roots – partially decomposed over millennia in boggy ground. When dried and burned, it produces smoke rich in phenols, aromatic compounds that cling to damp malted barley during drying.

These phenols – especially guaiacol and cresols – are responsible for the earthy, smoky, and sometimes medicinal notes found in peated whisky.

Peat levels vary by region. Islay whiskies are famously smoky, while most Speyside and Lowland whiskies use little or no peat. Highland distilleries often strike a balance. Peatiness is measured in phenol parts per million (PPM), with something like Highland Park at 15–20 PPM, while Laphroaig hits around 40 PPM. Cask type and aging also influence how smoke expresses itself.

Peated Whisky Beyond Scotland

Though Scotland remains the heart of peated whisky, the style has spread worldwide. Ireland offers soft, sweet peated expressions like Connemara. Japan’s Hakushu distillery produces refined, herbaceous smoky malts. India’s Paul John adds tropical warmth to its peated single malts. Each brings a unique twist to peat, broadening the experience for curious newcomers.

A Five-Step Peated Whisky Tasting Journey

Ready to explore peated whisky? Here’s a progression from mild to intense that will guide you through smoky flavors:

Highland Park 12 Year Old (Orkney, 43% ABV): A balanced single malt with honeyed malt, heather ,and gentle smokiness. Perfect for beginners as the peat presents as a subtle companion rather than the main event. Beginner tip: Add a few drops of water to open up the floral notes. Price: Around $50

Compass Box “The Peat Monster Arcana” (Blended Malt, 46% ABV): Despite its name, this offers approachable layers of peat. Expect chocolate, cinnamon and tarry smoke on the nose with a fruity palate and gradually building smokiness. Beginner tip: Try neat first, then add water to bring out more softness. Price: Around $90-$100

Talisker 10 Year Old (Isle of Skye, 45.8% ABV): A step up in intensity with distinctive maritime smokiness, wet seaweed, and campfire notes balanced by sweet fruit and black pepper spice. Beginner tip: Try with cool water to soften the peppery bite. Price: Around $50

Caol Ila 12 Year Old (Islay, 43% ABV): The “gentle giant” of Islay offers briny sea breeze, lemon, and sweet peat smoke. The palate is smooth with sweet malt, vanilla, and light bacon-like smoke. Beginner tip: Use a tulip-shaped glass to concentrate the aromas. Price: Around $60-$70

Laphroaig 10 Year Old (Islay, 43% ABV): A classic “peat monster” with intense medicinal character – iodine, seaweed, and smoke dominate, with subtle oak sweetness beneath. Beginner tip: Approach slowly; a few drops of water reveals hidden sweetness. Price: Approximately $40-$50