You’ve heard the names. You’ve seen the bottles. But what actually sets Jim Beam and Maker’s Mark apart?
Both are classic Kentucky bourbons, widely available and priced under $30. But once you pour a glass, the difference is immediate in taste, texture, and overall feel. Here’s how they compare, starting with the one thing that matters most: how they taste.
Jim Beam vs. Maker’s Mark: Taste Profiles
Jim Beam is light and dry. The nose opens with soft corn sweetness and a trace of nutty oak. On the palate, it’s mellow, with hints of caramel and a flicker of spice. It finishes clean and quick, making it an easy-drinking, no-frills bourbon.
Maker’s Mark is richer and rounder. The aroma leans into vanilla and soft fruit. The palate brings smooth caramel, cinnamon, and toasted oak. It feels fuller in the mouth and finishes with a warm, lingering sweetness.
Side by side, the difference is clear:
Maker’s is smoother and sweeter.
Beam is drier and spicier.
If you’re new to bourbon, you might find Maker’s more approachable. But if you enjoy a bit of bite, Beam’s classic profile might suit you better.
Jim Beam vs. Maker’s Mark: Side-by-Side Sips
What happens when you pour these two bourbons next to each other? A surprising amount, especially for first-time drinkers.
Jim Beam offers a drier, lighter profile. You’ll notice sweet corn and a touch of nutty oak on the nose, followed by mild caramel and a tingle of rye on the tongue. It’s mellow and easy, but doesn’t linger long.
Signup now to make sure you don't miss out on the latest whiskey news and deals.
By Signing up, you accept and agree to our Terms of Services and you acknowledge our Privacy Statement. The Whiskey Wash is protected by reCAPTCHA, and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Maker’s Mark comes across richer from the start. The nose leans sweet with vanilla and soft fruit, while the palate is full of caramel, cinnamon, and soft oak. It’s smoother and rounder, with a soft, warming finish.
Wheated bourbons like Maker’s Mark often appeal to people new to whiskey but some prefer the drier, punchier profile of a rye-based spirit like Beam.
Why the Difference? It Comes Down to One Grain
The biggest reason these two taste so different is all about the secondary grain in the recipe.
Jim Beam follows a traditional bourbon mash bill, using rye alongside corn and malted barley. Even in small amounts, rye adds spice, dryness, and a touch of bite, giving Beam its signature edge.
Maker’s Mark does things differently. Instead of rye, it uses soft red winter wheat. This single swap transforms the experience. Wheat softens the flavour, enhances sweetness, and gives Maker’s that famously smooth profile.
So when people say Maker’s is “easy to drink,” it’s not just marketing. That one grain really does shape the entire glass.
How They Perform: Neat, On the Rocks, or in a Cocktail?
Both bourbons are beginner-friendly, but they shine in different ways depending on how you serve them.
Neat, Maker’s Mark has the edge. Its fuller body and mellow sweetness make it a more satisfying sip on its own. Jim Beam is drinkable neat too, but it can come across as lighter and less complex.
With ice, Beam becomes ultra-smooth — almost too smooth if it gets over-diluted. Maker’s holds its flavour better, keeping that soft vanilla-oak balance even as the ice melts.
In cocktails, Beam’s rye backbone cuts through mixers nicely. It’s a great choice for a Whiskey Sour, Highball, or a simple bourbon and cola. Maker’s, meanwhile, shines in more spirit-forward drinks. Think Old Fashioned or Manhattan — drinks where sweetness, depth, and balance really matter.
Affordable Bourbon Battle
One reason these two are so often compared? They’re both easy to find and won’t dent your wallet.
Jim Beam White Label usually comes in at around $15–$20 for a 750ml bottle, making it one of the most affordable big-name bourbons out there.
Maker’s Mark is slightly pricier, typically $25–$30, but still firmly in everyday-drinking territory.
Both are widely available in supermarkets, bars, and online. Around the holidays, you’ll often see value gift packs with glasses or miniatures — a good way to try both if you’re still deciding.
What the Brands Say About Themselves
Jim Beam is all about tradition. Founded in 1795 and rebuilt after Prohibition by James B. Beam, the brand is now run by seventh-generation distillers Fred and Freddie Noe. It’s mass-produced, no-nonsense, and proud of its heritage. It is the bourbon equivalent of a reliable pickup truck or a well-worn leather jacket.
Maker’s Mark was created in 1953 with a different vision: a bourbon that was smoother and easier to sip. The brand leaned into craft before “craft” was cool: hand-rotated barrels, a wheated mash bill, and that iconic red wax seal. Maker’s feels curated but accessible, more like a smart blazer than a work shirt.
So… Jim Bim vs. Maker’s Mark: Which One Should You Choose?
If you want a light, dry, and spicy bourbon that mixes well and costs less, start with Jim Beam.
If you prefer a smooth, sweet, and full-bodied pour that drinks beautifully neat or on the rocks, go for Maker’s Mark.
Still not sure? Pick up a miniature of each and taste them side by side. You’ll quickly see how one small grain choice, rye or wheat, shapes the entire experience.
Whichever you choose, you’re starting your bourbon journey with a classic. Cheers.
Latest On The Whiskey Wash
